Gustav Holst - The Planets Op.32 Mars, the Bringer of War
BackGustav Holst - The Planets Op.32 Mars, the Bringer of War
Channel: Music
Uploaded: October 5, 2007 at 5:03 am
Author: lovelove0207
Length: 00:09:15
Rating: 4.86
Views: 160303
Tags: Gustav Holst The Planets Op.32 Mars the Bringer of War
Video Comments:
macree01 (November 23, 2008 at 1:33 pm)
I agree to disagree. Right now I have to go to a rehersal now, but I promise to continue this debate again in a couple of hours.
mrcoolgenius (November 23, 2008 at 12:31 pm)
No, it's because they think in different keys.
Trombones are 'built in Bb' but generally play in C bass clef (or C tenor). In a brass band and some brass ensembles though a trombone is in Bb and reads Bb treble. The same slide positions with the same lip pitching will still sound the same note, even though the player might call it a different note. It's the same with a euphonium, it transposes in different groups, but it's all the same in real pitch.
Trombones are 'built in Bb' but generally play in C bass clef (or C tenor). In a brass band and some brass ensembles though a trombone is in Bb and reads Bb treble. The same slide positions with the same lip pitching will still sound the same note, even though the player might call it a different note. It's the same with a euphonium, it transposes in different groups, but it's all the same in real pitch.
bari004 (November 23, 2008 at 12:24 pm)
im a euphonium player and i just want to clear up a few things... Euphonium is pitched in C if it is reading bass clef and it is pitched in Bb if it is reading treble clef.if you tell a treble cleff reader and a bass clef reader to play the same note, yes it will sound different unless they are playing the same cleff
macree01 (November 23, 2008 at 12:18 pm)
No they're not, some are in b flat and play in transposed treble cleff, more like a trumpet, and some are in c and play in bass clef, more like a trombone. There is a difference. If you ask a b flat euphonium and c euphonium player to play the same note, it would be diferent because they are both in differnet keys. If they are in different keys, then they are definatley not the same instrument.
krw239 (November 23, 2008 at 10:16 am)
Yeah, it sure looks like it.
mrcoolgenius (November 23, 2008 at 7:33 am)
I don't like the way the euphonium's done in this.
mrcoolgenius (November 23, 2008 at 7:32 am)
Erm, all euphoniums are in Bb, it's just if it's transposed for you or not.
macree01 (November 22, 2008 at 7:03 pm)
Its a different version of euphonium, yes, however a regular standard eupohnium is pitched in c. A tenor tuba pitched in b flat is just a fancy way of saying euphonium pitched in b flat. Pardon be by the way I didnt figure this stuff out until today. Basically when you see a euphonuim part in a concert band that is written in treble cleff, thats what tenor tuba in bflat is. A euphonium that is pitched in b flat and reads in treble cleff.
Bane0fmen (November 22, 2008 at 12:08 pm)
Ugh. Euphonium player didnt play loud enough.
mrcoolgenius (November 22, 2008 at 7:21 am)
A tenor tuba in Bb is a euphonium; they're just different names for the same thing. (Tenor tuba is the name more used by Americans, euphonium is European)
-
Links:
-
Tags:
hip-hop interviews videos r kelly usher eminem jay-z beyonce chris brown artist
